top of page

How to prepare for a 1:1 Meeting: Tips for a better conversation

Writer: Pat (PK) Kearney
Pat (PK) Kearney
3 days ago
4 min read

At the end of last year, I wrote a piece for managers on how to make 1:1s useful for the folks they lead. It focused on listening well, being present, and making the whole thing worth everyone’s time. This year, I want to flip it, so folks can show up really well to their 1:1s, make their boss’s life a little easier, and share what they’ve been up to. Here goes. 


Many folks just show up to their 1:1s. This isn’t entirely their fault. Often no one has told them how to prepare, and they aren’t sure why these meetings exist or what their manager is looking for. This piece is meant to help both the manager and the employee get more out of that time. 


Your manager only sees part of your work and is often coming straight from another meeting. They’re guessing whether to fix the thing you raise, approve it, or listen. You’re often guessing too: how polished your work needs to be, what it feeds into, and how it fits into the bigger picture. A lot of tension comes from all that guessing. A simple structure can cut down on the guesswork. It also helps you tell your manager clearly what you’re working on, why it matters, and what you need from them. 


Here’s something of a template. Start by connecting in whatever way works for your manager. For some, that’s a few minutes of catching up. For others, it’s getting straight to business. Then try these steps:


  1. Progress since we last met


Start here, with what has moved. It gets the meeting going, and it’s the part most people already know how to do. Report outcomes, not just activities. Your manager tells your story in rooms you aren’t in, so give them the information they need to do that well. Start a running list now, if you haven’t already. By this time next year, it’s your review prep. 


  1. What done looks like, and where it fits 


For each item, get the deadline and how good it needs to be. The 10/50/99 framework can help here. Or just ask, “Is this a draft to get reactions on, or a final?” This matters a lot for thorough people at fast-moving places. Most of the pull between getting it right and getting it out goes away once someone tells you which one they want this week.


Ask a couple of questions: What is this feeding into? What’s changed around me that I should know about? When you can see the end goal, you make better calls on your own. Asking for it also helps your manager think it through and tailor what they ask of you.


  1. Where I’m stuck and what I need


Name what you’re stuck on. A big part of a manager’s job is helping people get unstuck from whatever mess they’re in. They can’t do that without some information from you. Be specific: “I need X by Y date to keep this on track.” It might be more time, clearer direction, a decision, or an introduction to someone. It’s also a good time to sort out what is yours to decide. Plenty of people wait for permission they already have. 


Close with some clarity. Reflect back what you agreed to, then ask, “What would be most useful for me to bring next time?” Before you go, name one thing your manager did since last time that helped. Ron Friedman, author of Superteams, found that people on high-performing teams give and receive more appreciation than people on other teams.


When something new lands

If your manager asks you to take something on and you’re already full, try: “Happy to. Here’s what’s on my plate. What should I move?” In this way, a new request becomes a conversation about capacity, your manager makes the tradeoff, and you avoid overcommitting. In Slow Productivity, Cal Newport suggests keeping a simple document of everything you’re working on. Then “here’s what’s on my plate” is something you can pull up and show.


Making it easy on your manager

Send a quick message ahead of time, using the headings above with a line or two under each. It makes your manager’s job easier. If you don’t have anything for a section, skip it. Not every section needs filling every week. 


Here’s what that might look like:


Progress since we last met: [two or three things that moved]


What done looks like: Is [project] a draft for reactions, or a final? What’s it feeding into?


Where I’m stuck: [what you need, and by when]



A few reflection questions

  • What doesn’t your manager know about your work this year that they should? 

  • Which item on your plate are you treating as a final when it might be a draft? 

  • What’s harder than expected right now that you haven’t said out loud? 



If you manage people, consider sending this to your team with a note like this: “I’d like to try this format in our next 1:1. It helps me know where I can be most useful to you.” And if you report to someone, send it their way and ask to try it. 


What did I miss? What else would you add? 



 
 

Let's Talk

©2024 Eddyline Coaching, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

1ftp_BusinessMember_Horizontal_White_edi
bottom of page